The Grange Players
Present:
Holmes for the Holidays
11.01.17 - 21.01.17
The trepidation awaiting a critic’s review can be a daunting prospect. As an actor myself, I empathise with any cast or production team member who would echo the play’s line ‘She was ruthless. She was evil! She was a theatre-critic for God’s sake!’ Be reassured. The ‘Holmes for the Holidays’ team should have no such anxieties: there is much to praise in this show.
Attending The Grange theatre for the first time, any trace of apprehensions I might have held were soon dispersed. This is a space of welcome, a place of shared experience where theatre is enjoyed. The warmth and efficiency of the gentleman manning the ticket desk thawed me as I stepped beyond the reach of the cold, snowy night outside. The auditorium’s rake of comfortable seating was soon filled almost to capacity - no mean feat for any theatre on a night in mid-January. In the half-lit atmosphere of this intimate proscenium venue, an expectancy of enjoyment pervaded before curtain-up.
The venue is pertinent, for this play of two acts, set in the Christmas period of 1936, would not sit half so well in a pared-down, black-box space. It provides a seamless complement to the masterfully tailored set, which supplies both period aesthetic and functionality for essential stage-business.
In many theatre pieces of this nature, the technicals shine when appropriate and effective without being intrusive, and for this very reason can often be overlooked. On this criteria, the show’s sound and lighting design, intrinsic to the play’s telling, were impeccable. Costume and properties were made well to purpose and would serve a several-month run.
‘Holmes for the Holidays’ is the pen-work of ‘the purveyor of light comedy to middle America’ (show programme, citing The Times, 2006) Ken Ludwig, and the director and cast do well to present the piece to a British audience and maintain its distinctive US flavour throughout. A rapid East coast patter between William Gillette (Robert Meehan) and his houseguests is supported by all the cast with fluent accent, manner and interaction. Whilst at times the first act feels a little expositional, by the interval this ensemble immerse the audience thoroughly in the small 1930s world of egos, friendships, insecurities and trusts between actors who strut the stage. The wonderfully executed slapstick, delivered without excess by characters Daria Chase, Felix Gisel and William Gillette (Liz Webster, Sam Evans, Robert Meehan), adds to the humour and harkens back subtly to 1930s comedy styles.
Act two witnesses the Sherlock actor Gillette don his robes and pit his wits to the challenge of solving the case, and here the energy changes: there’s a murderer at large, and the drawing-room banter and revelations are superseded by purposeful activity. This, together with the introduction of Inspector Goring, adeptly played by Suzy Donnelly, lends more of the familiar territory of the who-dunnit and drives the pace to the final scenes.
There are conventions and concepts within ‘Holmes for the Holidays’ that will be recognisable to many actors and, whilst it is not essential to appreciate these to enjoy a performance, it may be a service for any reviewer here to highlight them to a potential audience member. The first scene is brief in nature, and in the spirit of ‘in late/out early’ begins mid-action without preamble at the curtain-call of a particular Sherlock Holmes performance. The piece assumes a conventional linear plot structure from the start. An awareness of this may avoid some confusion.
The prevalence of characters (not actors) taking the limelight and declaiming in the piece may also initially startle. The quoting of famous dramatic pieces, the basking in the approval of peers, all this expression of talent or ego amongst Gillette’s guests seems the hallmark of actors in each others company, and it takes a skilled ensemble to pull this off well. We watch actors performing the roles of 1930s stage actors, and it is good to accept that what they do is credible and naturalistic.
Directed by Chris Waters, ‘Holmes for the Holidays’ runs from 11th through to 21st January 2017.
Review by Anthony Webster
